Hybrid Collectives

A hybrid collective combines parties of different kinds in one decision. Identity is the first question in each case, because the parties describe each other differently and an outside study adds a third description (Agency, Agentic Stair). This note traces who senses, who interprets, who can stop whom, and what changed when states, markets or technologies intervened. It covers two sets of cases. In the first set, people decide with other species and with places, and several cases come from customary and Indigenous governance. In the second set, engineers join living bodies with machines: animals with robots, neurons with computers, people with algorithms. Each case combines several styles from Styles Settled by Assessment, Styles Settled by Variation and Styles Settled Among Parties. Decision Styles defines the terms and the labels "proposed", "contested" and "model".

People with Other Species and Places

For cases from customary and Indigenous governance, the table separates what a people's own account states from what a study observed.

Collective and decisionWhat the other party doesHow refusal and control passStyles combinedEvidence
Net-casting fishers and Lahille's bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus gephyreus) in Laguna, Brazil: when to cast the netDolphins herd mullet (Mugil liza) toward the fishers and give a cue, commonly a sudden deep diveEither party can act without the other. Fishers cast without a cue in about a third of 2,805 recorded events, and dolphins gave a cue without a cast in about 9%. Fishers caught more only when cast and cue matched. In those bouts, dolphins dived for longer and made more feeding buzzes, which the authors read as foraging success. Dolphins now fish with people less often, and the fishers who take part have fewer years of experience. Illegal nets kill dolphins, mostly those that do not fish with peopleSignals across species; synchronised timing; tradition; mutual adjustmentField measurement of both parties1
Honey-hunters of the Boran, Yao and Hadza and greater honeyguides (Indicator indicator) in eastern and southern Africa: whether to hunt and which way to walkThe bird approaches people or answers their call, gives a call that it uses only for this purpose and flies toward a bees' nestThe bird leads, and the hunters follow and open the nest. In playback experiments in Tanzania and Mozambique, honeyguides answered the call of the local people about three times as often as the call of the other people, so the birds' learned preference maintains each human tradition.2 Hadza men found bees' nests at 3.3 nests an hour when a bird guided them and at 0.5 nests an hour without one. They did not repay the birds: they hid, buried or burned the comb, with the intent of keeping the birds hungry so that they guide again.3 Regular cooperation survives in few areas. Reviewers identify bee-keeping and other sources of sugar as likely replacements for honey-hunting, and they report that parks that exclude residents have ended the cooperation in parts of AfricaLeadership granted by followers; signals across species; tradition; steeringReview of experiments, observation and ethnography4, 5
Chisasibi Cree hunters and caribou (Rangifer tarandus) at James Bay, Canada: how to conduct the huntIn the Cree account, animals control the success of a hunt and answer disrespect by staying awayAfter a wasteful hunt in 1983–4, almost no caribou came to the road in the next winter. Two elders retold the story of a slaughter in the 1910s and of the disappearance that followed. In 1985–6, hunters took 867 caribou with little waste, and the Cree Trappers Association monitored the hunt. The herd had come onto a road that served a new hydroelectric dam, and hunters carried caribou away by the truckloadRefusal as the hunters read it; tradition; leadership by elders; rules of a self-managing associationEthnography with harvest data6
Rakiura Māori birders and tītī (sooty shearwater, Puffinus griseus) in southern New Zealand: whether to start a night's harvest and when to stopThe chicks' numbers and their emergence from burrows set the catch rate that birders read, and birders also judge the chicks' fatnessBirders do not start when conditions promise a low catch rate. Skilled birders keep the rate up by choosing place, weather and time, so the catch rate follows the birds' numbers poorly. Families with many birds per harvester noticed little change over decades of decline, while other families saw their catch rates fall. Under co-management, a comparison of catch rates with counts of chicks in burrows widened agreement among families that the birds were decliningValue comparison; satisficing; own memory in harvest records; formal analysisReview of the authors' field studies7
Clan chiefs and reef fishes at Muluk on Karkar Island, Papua New Guinea: when to close a reef to fishing and when to reopen itIn the villagers' account, fish keep farther from spear fishers when fishing is heavy and grow tame after a restThe three clan chiefs close about 58 hectares for one to two years when catches fall and fish flee at a distance. They reopen the reef when fish allow a close approach. At Kakarotan, Indonesia, an annual feast sets the timing of a comparable closure. The biomass of target fishes was 25% and 37% greater in the two periodically closed areas than at sites open all year; the Kakarotan area was open to fishing when the survey took placeAvoidance read as a signal; customary rule; leadershipFish counts in periodically closed areas and at open sites, with interviews8
Yolŋu families at Bawaka, and Aboriginal people of the Victoria River valley and of the floodplains south-west of Darwin, northern Australia: when to hunt, gather and burnIn the knowledge of each country, one event indicates another. Wattle flowers when turtles come to lay (Bawaka), March flies bite when crocodiles lay (Victoria River), and the flowering of silky oak (Grevillea pteridifolia) is one sign to start burning (floodplains)Only people who know a country can read its signs, because the same sign indicates different events in different countries. A knowledge holder of the floodplains says that nobody would try to burn someone else's country. In the Yolŋu account, Country sends messages, and people may attend to them or miss themAnticipation from a cue; tradition; customary lawEthnography with Yolŋu and other Aboriginal knowledge holders9, 10
Sgaw Karen villagers and the spirit owners of water and land in the Salween Peace Park, on the border of Thailand and Burma: which plot a family may clearIn the Karen account, the spirit owners allow people to farm in return for offerings and moral conduct. Other invisible beings demand deference, and people do not clear the places where those beings dwellEach family consults a diviner on whether its chosen plot is propitious and makes offerings to the spirit owners before it clears. Hereditary ceremonial leaders lead a day of rest beforehand and by tradition perform each ceremony first. After an illness or injury, a diviner identifies the violation and prescribes restitution. Burmese state policy classes the communal land as vacant, and the ceremonies have declined in many areas under central controlDivination; tradition; leadership; sanctionsInterview study with participant observation11
River guardians for the Martuwarra (Fitzroy River), Western Australia, the Río Atrato, Colombia, and the Whanganui River, Aotearoa New Zealand: who may take, dam or pollute the waterIn First Law, the Martuwarra is a living ancestral being with its own right to life. For the Atrato, a court ordered guardians. For the Whanganui, an act of parliament recognises the river as a legal personThe guardians can speak and cannot stop others. Native title gives the Martuwarra nations no veto over dams, extraction or mining. Atrato guardians report that mining machinery still reaches the river bed. An assessment four years after the Atrato ruling found plans made with the community guardians and a stronger community voice in policy. The guardians' capacity to claim damages for the river had played no role, and the river's condition showed no concrete improvement.12 On the Whanganui, the river's stated values reframed the aims of a port project and put a hapū-led collective at the centre of its decisions. The design changes that the study records answered residents' wishes for recreation areas and river views, and the study records no decision that the river's interests blocked13Representation and guardianship; written rule; contestLegal analysis;14 interview studies15
Dairy farmers, cows and milking robots in the United Kingdom: when each cow is milkedCows walk in, stay away, overstay, kick the robots or guard them from herd-matesManufacturers say that decisions pass from the farmer to the cow. Farmers nudge cows out of the robot, coerce cows that stay away and train cows. Data from the robots give farmers new means to control cows, and farms come to depend on the manufacturers' engineers and advice. Farmers call a cow that stays away lazy, while the study suggests that lameness, bullying, diet and the demand for yield can produce such conductDelegation to automated systems; dominance within the herd; steeringInterview study with observation on farms16
Free-living beavers (Castor fiber), residents and state agencies on the River Otter, England: whether the beavers stayThe beavers were living on the river before any authority decided anything. Nobody has established whether people released them or they escaped from captivityA minister announced that the beavers would be recaptured and rehomed in captivity. Public dissent and a wildlife trust's proposal led to a five-year trial licence. Under it, the beavers were trapped, tested for disease, tagged and released again, and they stay under monitoringContest; representation; written ruleInterview study and document analysis17

Living Bodies with Machines

In these composites, a builder decides in advance which part can stimulate which and which part can read which. The table asks the same questions of them. A review of such systems defines hybrots and animats as cultures of neurons coupled in closed loops to robots or to simulated animals. It defines cyborgs as tissues joined with engineered interfaces, so that cells can control machines and machines can control cells.18

Composite and decisionWhat each part doesHow refusal and control passStyles combinedEvidence
Cockroaches and small robots in one arena: which shelter the group rests underThe robots wore paper with the odour of cockroaches, and the cockroaches treated them as group membersThe choice arose from local interactions among all members. Robots that were programmed to prefer the lighter shelter changed the choice even when they were in the minority: mixed groups chose that shelter in 61% of trials, and cockroaches alone in 27%. In 39% of trials the cockroaches drew the robots into the darker shelter. The authors present the robots as a means to study and to control the collective behaviour of animalsAlignment with neighbours; steeringLaboratory experiment19
Honeybees (Apis mellifera) in Graz, Austria, and zebrafish (Danio rerio) in Lausanne, Switzerland, linked through robots: beside which of two robots the bees gather, and in which direction the fish swim around a ringIn each group, robots stimulated the animals and sensed their behaviour. A long-distance link passed that information between the two sets of robotsCollective decisions emerged between the two robotic systems and the two animal groups, so each species influenced the other through a channel that only the robots provide. The authors see a route to control of behaviour in groups of several speciesAlignment with neighbours; signals across species; delegation to automated systemsLaboratory experiment20
Cultured cortical neurons, from mice or from human stem cells, and a simulated game of Pong: how to move the paddleStimulation of a sensory area of the electrode array encoded the position of the ball, and activity in two motor regions moved the paddle up or downA hit returned predictable stimulation and a miss returned random stimulation. Play improved within five minutes. Cultures that received stimulation without feedback showed no learning. The authors call the result synthetic biological intelligence and claim sentience. A published response disputes both claims (contested)Active inference; trial and errorLaboratory experiment;21 response22
Stem cells of frog embryos (Xenopus laevis), an evolutionary algorithm and human builders: which body to buildThe algorithm evolved designs toward a behavioural goal in simulation. Builders assembled the best designs from the cellsThe program selected the form, and the cells then kept it and closed lacerations by their own means. Motile organisms also gathered loose particles spontaneously, in simulation and in the dishGenerative search; selection among variants; developmental target-seekingDesign pipeline with laboratory tests23
Beetles (Mecynorrhina torquata and Cotinis texana) with radio receivers and electrodes: when to fly and where to turnStimulation of the brain started and stopped wing oscillation. Stimulation of flight muscles produced turns. The beetle powered its own flight and kept levelThe operator applied a command whenever a change of heading or of height was required, and the beetle kept the rest of flight control. The channel ran one way, from the operator to the beetleSteering; dominanceLaboratory experiment24
Linked brains, in four rats and in three people: which answer the group givesIn the rats, electrodes in the somatosensory cortex recorded the activity of each animal and delivered it to the others.25 In the people, a receiver got the decisions of two senders through magnetic stimulation and then decided26The linked rats performed several tasks as well as single rats or better. Receivers learned to trust the more reliable sender when the experimenters added noise to one sender's signal, and five groups reached an average accuracy of 81.25%Voting and averaging; own memoryLaboratory experiments
Bean plants, climbing plants and controllers that supply light or other stimuli: where to growThe plant grows toward or away from stimuli by its own tropisms. A controller learns the plant's responses from images and sets the stimuliControllers steered bean plants to targets and around obstacles. In work with climbing plants, robots supply stimuli that guide the plant's choice between growth paths. The reviewers identify the steering of growth as the main challenge for buildings that plants and robots construct togetherGrowth allocation; steering; supported constructionReview of early research27
People and forecasting algorithms: whose forecast to useThe algorithm forecasts more accurately than the human forecasterPeople who had seen the algorithm err chose the human forecaster, because they lost confidence in the algorithm faster than in a human who made the same mistakeDelegation to automated systems; avoidance and non-useExperiments28
People and software agents in networks of 20: which colour each member takesThree software agents in central positions acted with a small amount of random noiseThe noise shortened the median time to a solution by 55.6%, and it changed how the people played among themselves. The experimenters chose the agents' positions and their level of noiseRandomising; alignment with neighboursExperiments with 4,000 people in 230 networks29

What the Cases Show

  • The other parties take different roles. They act as sources of signals (tītī, wattle, March flies, reef fishes), as partners that can withhold cooperation (dolphins, honeyguides), as leaders, as authorities in a people's law (spirit owners, rivers, Country), as settlers whose presence sets off a decision (beavers), as refusers in the hunters' reading (caribou), and as animals whose conduct departs from the plans of farmers and manufacturers (cows). In the engineered composites, they act as group members (cockroaches), as learners (neurons), as builders of their own bodies (frog cells) and as carriers of commands (beetles).
  • Leading animals are documented in herding and riding. In the Cairngorms, Scotland, herders gave the lead of the herd to a reindeer ox. The ox walked at the head and decided the direction along the herd's traditional routes, the herders followed close behind, and the ox in turn answered their calls.30 In the territory of the Xeni Gwet'in in British Columbia, backcountry riders trust the instincts of a horse raised in the bush when they choose a route around obstacles and wildlife.31 A comparison of six herding systems in Siberia and Mongolia found that herders rely mostly on the animals' own ability to feed, protect and orient themselves. Herders apply their influence through lead animals, for example by fitting old lead females with bells.32 Komi and Nenets herders in northern Russia move when the reindeer no longer want to stay on a pasture. When an enterprise ordered Nenets herders to repair a corral, the work kept the camp on unsuitable pasture, the herd dispersed, and the herders abandoned the repair.33
  • Influence passes through reading, and readings differ. In the sign cases, another species' act supplies the information, and people with the right knowledge act on it. The sources describe this as Country calling people into action.10, 9 Inclusion (Private) argues that such knowledge of other beings remains human knowledge. Both readings agree on what an observer can test: whether the decision changes when the sign changes. A reading can also follow the other party's condition poorly. Catch rates hid the decline of tītī from families that harvest where birds are plentiful, while other birders noticed the decline and prompted the research into its causes.7 In Nunavut, Canada, Inuit reports of more polar bears (Ursus maritimus) near communities led a minister to raise hunting quotas in 2005, while scientists estimated declines and related the sightings to an earlier break-up of sea ice.34 Design workflows meet the same limit. In one workflow, trees supply branches, birds accept or reject them, and humans and programs read those responses.35 A study of design for owls concludes that owls can voice preferences through behaviour and that humans inevitably mediate such voices.36
  • Refusal counts when the outcome changes. The agentic stair tests power by asking whether the outcome changes when the other party rejects an option (Agentic Stair). The outcome changed in the Cree hunt, where hunters read the caribou's absence as refusal. At Laguna, the fishers' catch depends on the dolphins' cue. The outcome did not change for the river guardians where mining and dams are concerned. Kluane First Nation hunters in the Yukon describe animals that give or withhold themselves, and these accounts never became the basis of decisions in co-management meetings.37 People refused a forecasting algorithm with effect, because the choice was theirs.28 The steered beetle had no channel for refusal.24
  • The cited studies document authority in a people's law as practice. They record what people say and do, and most do not test an effect. A study with Urarina communities in the Peruvian Amazon reports that fear of tree spirits restrains the felling of many trees and that fear of the spirit owners of palm swamps may deter overuse. It states that it cannot measure an ecological effect of the spirit owners.38 One field test concerns Martu accounts in the Western Desert of Australia, which state that plants and animals cease when people stop hunting and burning. Burrows of the sand monitor (Varanus gouldii) were more frequent where Martu hunted more intensively and near the edges of burns.39 A ritual rule can also have a stated ecological logic. In northern California, nobody took fresh salmon at the start of the spring run until a ritual specialist had completed the first-salmon rite. The Yurok took down their fish dam at Kepel after ten days, so that the run reached groups upriver.40
  • The conditions of a decision change when states, markets or technologies enter. A dam road, illegal nets, other sources of sugar, a land classification and a milking robot each changed the conditions of a decision in the cases above: access to the herd, the deaths of dolphins, the need for a guide, tenure, and dependence on a supplier. Range managers classed the horses of the Xeni Gwet'in as feral pests and tried to remove them for decades.31 In Bali, rice farmers limit pests when neighbours plant together and limit water shortage when they stagger their planting. A state policy of the 1970s ended the coordinated schedules, and pest outbreaks followed until farmers returned to synchronised planting.41 A rule can also lose its other party when a state adopts it. Gwich'in hunters let the first caribou of the Porcupine herd pass so that the herd follows the leaders' trail. In the mid-1990s, a Gwich'in council asked the co-management board for a closure. In 2000, the Yukon government made the practice a one-week closure of hunting along the Dempster Highway, and it stopped enforcement in 2007 after a hunter of another First Nation challenged a charge. The regulation had replaced the hunters' judgement of when the leaders had passed with a closure of fixed length, timed to the caribou's first arrival near the highway.42 The other party can also gain room. Public dissent in defence of the beavers forced a compromise, a licence under which the beavers stay on trial, and self-management rights allowed Cree hunters to answer the caribou.
  • Technical systems move authority to those who control them. Technical systems can make decisions without direct human intervention, and they enter worlds that other beings already inhabit.43 On dairy farms, robots gave farmers new means of control, although their makers announced a transfer of decisions to cows.16 Analysts of participation report that authority over decisions often concentrates in those who control technical systems.44 A review of digital ecologies describes governance that is spread across human actors, sensors, data infrastructures and algorithms. The animals in it appear as tracked sentinels.45 In the laboratory composites, the experimenters programmed the robots, designed the neurons' feedback and issued the beetles' commands. One perspective paper considers a further step: humans and artificial intelligence could become one evolving unit if artificial intelligence passes from parents to offspring as part of development, and the part with regulatory control need not be the biological part. Its author calls the analysis speculative.46
  • Control runs both ways only in closed loops. The neurons improved only when the consequences of their activity returned to them,21 and the robots changed the cockroaches' choice because they took part in the same local interactions.19 Where the channel runs one way, as in the steered beetle, the composite executes the operator's decision.24 A forecast about superintelligent systems expects the same question at a larger scale: whether a system answers questions, executes commands or acts under an open mandate decides which human precautions remain possible (proposed).47
  • A signal binds when a rule binds humans to it. In the southern Gulf of St Lawrence, Canada, one confirmed sighting of a North Atlantic right whale (Eubalaena glacialis), and since 2020 one acoustic detection, closes an area to snow crab fishing for 15 days. A model estimates that the closures of 2018 to 2021, fixed and triggered together, and an earlier end of the season removed about 62% of the relative risk of entanglement.48 By contrast, an advisory map of the likely presence of loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) had little effect on where Hawaiian longline fishers set their gear.49
  • Small settings show how refusal can gain force. At a sanctuary for formerly farmed animals in Vermont, staff changed the daily health check after feedback from the birds and let a frail cow join the herd that she chose. Staff still override some choices, for example when they shut in a rooster at night.50 Guide dogs learn to refuse a cue that would lead their handler into danger. Handlers can override the refusal, and participants in one interview study reported falls after handlers walked on when the dog had stopped.51
  • Some reports await tests. Aboriginal rangers in northern Australia allow for raptors that carry burning sticks across firebreaks. The evidence consists of interviews and observations, with no experiment. Official scepticism hampers fire planning.52
  • Styles overlap in every case. The fourth column of each table lists two to four styles for each collective. The eel notes describe further cases of seasonal signs and customary closures (Anguillid Eels, Eel Names and Languages).

References


Footnotes

  1. Cantor, Maurício, Damien R. Farine, and Fábio G. Daura-Jorge. “Foraging Synchrony Drives Resilience in Human–Dolphin Mutualism.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120, no. 6 (2023): e2207739120. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2207739120.˄

  2. Spottiswoode, Claire N., and Brian M. Wood. “Culturally Determined Interspecies Communication between Humans and Honeyguides.” Science 382, no. 6675 (2023): 1155–58. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adh4129.˄

  3. Wood, Brian M., Herman Pontzer, David A. Raichlen, and Frank W. Marlowe. “Mutualism and Manipulation in Hadza–Honeyguide Interactions.” Evolution and Human Behavior 35, no. 6 (2014): 540–46. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2014.07.007.˄

  4. Cram, Dominic L., Jessica E. M. van der Wal, Natalie T. Uomini, Maurício Cantor, Anap I. Afan, Mairenn C. Attwood, Jenny Amphaeris, et al. “The Ecology and Evolution of Human-Wildlife Cooperation.” People and Nature 4, no. 4 (2022): 841–55. https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.10369.˄

  5. Wal, Jessica E. M. van der, Claire N. Spottiswoode, Natalie T. Uomini, Maurício Cantor, Fábio G. Daura-Jorge, Anap I. Afan, Mairenn C. Attwood, et al. “Safeguarding Human–Wildlife Cooperation.” Conservation Letters 15, no. 4 (2022): e12886. https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12886.˄

  6. Berkes, Fikret. Sacred Ecology. 1999. 3rd ed. Abingdon: Routledge, 2012.˄

  7. Moller, Henrik, Fikret Berkes, Philip O’Brian Lyver, and Mina Kislalioglu. “Combining Science and Traditional Ecological Knowledge: Monitoring Populations for Co-Management.” Ecology and Society 9, no. 3 (2004): 2. https://doi.org/10.5751/es-00675-090302.˄

  8. Cinner, Joshua E., Michael J. Marnane, Tim R. McClanahan, and Glenn R. Almany. “Periodic Closures as Adaptive Coral Reef Management in the Indo-Pacific.” Ecology and Society 11, no. 1 (2006): 31. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-01618-110131.˄

  9. Bawaka Country, Sandie Suchet-Pearson, Sarah Wright, Kate Lloyd, and Laklak Burarrwanga. “Caring as Country: Towards an Ontology of Co-Becoming in Natural Resource Management.” Asia Pacific Viewpoint 54, no. 2 (2013): 185–97. https://doi.org/10.1111/apv.12018.˄

  10. Rose, Deborah Bird. “An Indigenous Philosophical Ecology: Situating the Human.” The Australian Journal of Anthropology 16, no. 3 (2005): 294–305. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1835-9310.2005.tb00312.x.˄

  11. Paul, Andrew, Robin Roth, and Saw Sha Bwe Moo. “Relational Ontology and More-than-Human Agency in Indigenous Karen Conservation Practice.” Pacific Conservation Biology 27, no. 4 (2021): 376–90. https://doi.org/10.1071/pc20016.˄

  12. Wesche, Philipp. “Rights of Nature in Practice: A Case Study on the Impacts of the Colombian Atrato River Decision.” Journal of Environmental Law 33, no. 3 (2021): 531–55. https://doi.org/10.1093/jel/eqab021.˄

  13. Cribb, Miriama, Elizabeth Macpherson, and Axel Borchgrevink. “Beyond Legal Personhood for the Whanganui River: Collaboration and Pluralism in Implementing the Te Awa Tupua Act.” The International Journal of Human Rights, ahead of print, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1080/13642987.2024.2314532.˄

  14. RiverOfLife, Martuwarra, Anne Poelina, Donna Bagnall, and Michelle Lim. “Recognizing the Martuwarra’s First Law Right to Life as a Living Ancestral Being.” Transnational Environmental Law 9, no. 3 (2020): 541–68. https://doi.org/10.1017/s2047102520000163.˄

  15. Cano-Pecharroman, Lidia, and Erin O’Donnell. “Relational Representation: Speaking with and Not about Nature.” PLOS Water 3, no. 10 (2024): e0000236. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000236.˄

  16. Bear, Christopher, and Lewis Holloway. “Beyond Resistance: Geographies of Divergent More-than-Human Conduct in Robotic Milking.” Geoforum 104 (2019): 212–21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2019.04.030.˄

  17. Crowley, Sarah L., Steve Hinchliffe, and Robbie A. McDonald. “Nonhuman Citizens on Trial: The Ecological Politics of a Beaver Reintroduction.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 49, no. 8 (2017): 1846–66. https://doi.org/10.1177/0308518x17705133.˄

  18. Clawson, Wesley P., and Michael Levin. “Endless Forms Most Beautiful 2.0: Teleonomy and the Bioengineering of Chimaeric and Synthetic Organisms.” Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 139, no. 4 (2023): 457–86. https://doi.org/10.1093/biolinnean/blac073.˄

  19. Halloy, José, Grégory Sempo, Gilles Caprari, Colette Rivault, Masoud Asadpour, Fabien Tâche, Imen Saïd, et al. “Social Integration of Robots into Groups of Cockroaches to Control Self-Organized Choices.” Science 318, no. 5853 (2007): 1155–58. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1144259.˄

  20. Bonnet, Frank, Rob Mills, Martina Szopek, Sarah Schönwetter-Fuchs, José Halloy, Stjepan Bogdan, Luís Correia, Francesco Mondada, and Thomas Schmickl. “Robots Mediating Interactions between Animals for Interspecies Collective Behaviors.” Science Robotics 4, no. 28 (2019): eaau7897. https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.aau7897.˄

  21. Kagan, Brett J., Andy C. Kitchen, Nhi T. Tran, Forough Habibollahi, Moein Khajehnejad, Bradyn J. Parker, Anjali Bhat, Ben Rollo, Adeel Razi, and Karl J. Friston. “In vitro Neurons Learn and Exhibit Sentience When Embodied in a Simulated Game-World.” Neuron 110, no. 23 (2022): 3952-3969.e8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2022.09.001.˄

  22. Balci, Fuat, Suliann Ben Hamed, Thomas Boraud, Sébastien Bouret, Thomas Brochier, Cédric Brun, Jeremiah Y. Cohen, et al. “A Response to Claims of Emergent Intelligence and Sentience in a Dish.” Neuron 111, no. 5 (2023): 604–5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2023.02.009.˄

  23. Kriegman, Sam, Douglas Blackiston, Michael Levin, and Josh Bongard. “A Scalable Pipeline for Designing Reconfigurable Organisms.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117, no. 4 (2020): 1853–59. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1910837117.˄

  24. Sato, Hirotaka, Christopher W. Berry, Yoav Peeri, Emen Baghoomian, Brendan E. Casey, Gabriel Lavella, John M. VandenBrooks, Jon F. Harrison, and Michel M. Maharbiz. “Remote Radio Control of Insect Flight.” Frontiers in Integrative Neuroscience 3 (2009): 24. https://doi.org/10.3389/neuro.07.024.2009.˄

  25. Pais-Vieira, Miguel, Gabriela Chiuffa, Mikhail Lebedev, Amol Yadav, and Miguel A. L. Nicolelis. “Building an Organic Computing Device with Multiple Interconnected Brains.” Scientific Reports 5, no. 1 (2015): 11869. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep11869.˄

  26. Jiang, Linxing, Andrea Stocco, Darby M. Losey, Justin A. Abernethy, Chantel S. Prat, and Rajesh P. N. Rao. “BrainNet: A Multi-Person Brain-to-Brain Interface for Direct Collaboration between Brains.” Scientific Reports 9, no. 1 (2019): 6115. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-41895-7.˄

  27. Heinrich, Mary Katherine, Sebastian von Mammen, Daniel Nicolas Hofstadler, Mostafa Wahby, Payam Zahadat, Tomasz Skrzypczak, Mohammad Divband Soorati, et al. “Constructing Living Buildings: A Review of Relevant Technologies for a Novel Application of Biohybrid Robotics.” Journal of The Royal Society Interface 16, no. 156 (2019): 20190238. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2019.0238.˄

  28. Dietvorst, Berkeley J., Joseph P. Simmons, and Cade Massey. “Algorithm Aversion: People Erroneously Avoid Algorithms after Seeing Them Err.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 144, no. 1 (2015): 114–26. https://doi.org/10.1037/xge0000033.˄

  29. Shirado, Hirokazu, and Nicholas A. Christakis. “Locally Noisy Autonomous Agents Improve Global Human Coordination in Network Experiments.” Nature 545, no. 7654 (2017): 370–74. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature22332.˄

  30. Lorimer, Hayden. “Herding Memories of Humans and Animals.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 24, no. 4 (2006): 497–518. https://doi.org/10.1068/d381t.˄

  31. Bhattacharyya, Jonaki, and Scott Slocombe. “Animal Agency: Wildlife Management from a Kincentric Perspective.” Ecosphere 8, no. 10 (2017): e01978. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecs2.1978.˄

  32. Stépanoff, Charles, Charlotte Marchina, Camille Fossier, and Nicolas Bureau. “Animal Autonomy and Intermittent Coexistences: North Asian Modes of Herding.” Current Anthropology 58, no. 1 (2017): 57–81. https://doi.org/10.1086/690120.˄

  33. Dwyer, Mark J., and Kirill V. Istomin. “Theories of Nomadic Movement: A New Theoretical Approach for Understanding the Movement Decisions of Nenets and Komi Reindeer Herders.” Human Ecology 36, no. 4 (2008): 521–33. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10745-008-9169-2.˄

  34. Dowsley, Martha, and George Wenzel. “‘The Time of the Most Polar Bears’: A Co-Management Conflict in Nunavut.” Arctic 61, no. 2 (2008): 177–89. https://doi.org/10.14430/arctic56.˄

  35. Holland, Alexander, and Stanislav Roudavski. “Participatory Design for Multispecies Cohabitation: by Trees, for Birds, with Humans.” In Designing More-than-Human Smart Cities: Beyond Sustainability, towards Cohabitation, edited by Sara Heitlinger, Marcus Foth, and Rachel Clarke, 93–128. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1093/9780191980060.003.0007.˄

  36. Parker, Dan, Kylie Soanes, and Stanislav Roudavski. “Interspecies Cultures and Future Design.” Transpositiones 1, no. 1 (2022): 183–236. https://doi.org/10.14220/trns.2022.1.1.183.˄

  37. Nadasdy, Paul. “The Gift in the Animal: The Ontology of Hunting and Human–Animal Sociality.” American Ethnologist 34, no. 1 (2007): 25–43. https://doi.org/10.1525/ae.2007.34.1.25.˄

  38. Fabiano, Emanuele, Christopher Schulz, and Manuel Martín Brañas. “Wetland Spirits and Indigenous Knowledge: Implications for the Conservation of Wetlands in the Peruvian Amazon.” Current Research in Environmental Sustainability 3 (2021): 100107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crsust.2021.100107.˄

  39. Bliege Bird, Rebecca, Nyalangka Taylor, Brian F. Codding, and Douglas W. Bird. “Niche Construction and Dreaming Logic: Aboriginal Patch Mosaic Burning and Varanid Lizards (Varanus gouldii) in Australia.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 280, no. 1772 (2013): 20132297. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2013.2297.˄

  40. Swezey, Sean L., and Robert F. Heizer. “Ritual Management of Salmonid Fish Resources in California.” The Journal of California Anthropology 4, no. 1 (1977): 6–29.˄

  41. Lansing, J. Stephen, Stefan Thurner, Ning Ning Chung, Aurélie Coudurier-Curveur, Çağil Karakaş, Kurt A. Fesenmyer, and Lock Yue Chew. “Adaptive Self-Organization of Bali’s Ancient Rice Terraces.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114, no. 25 (2017): 6504–9. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1605369114.˄

  42. Padilla, Elisabeth, and Gary P. Kofinas. “‘Letting the Leaders Pass’: Barriers to Using Traditional Ecological Knowledge in Comanagement as the Basis of Formal Hunting Regulations.” Ecology and Society 19, no. 2 (2014): 7. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-05999-190207.˄

  43. Brock, Douglas, and Stanislav Roudavski. “Sentience and Place: Towards More-than-Human Cultures.” In Why Sentience? Proceedings of the 26th International Symposium on Electronic Arts (ISEA 2020), edited by Christine Ross and Chris Salter, 83–90. Montreal: Printemps Numérique/ISEA, 2020. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4149395.˄

  44. Giaccardi, Elisa, Stanislav Roudavski, and Martín Tironi. “Participation and the Troubles with Intelligence.” In PDC ’26: Proceedings of the 19th Participatory Design Conference 2026, vol. 1, edited by Daniela Selloni, Anna Meroni, Laura Galluzzo, Davide Fassi, Daniela de Sainz, Stefana Broadbent, Angus Campbell, et al., 385–90. New York: Association for Computing Machinery, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1145/3796624.3796632.˄

  45. Turnbull, Jonathon, Adam Searle, Oscar Hartman Davies, Jennifer Dodsworth, Pauline Chasseray-Peraldi, Erica von Essen, and Henry Anderson-Elliott. “Digital Ecologies: Materialities, Encounters, Governance.” Progress in Environmental Geography 2, nos. 1–2 (2023): 3–32. https://doi.org/10.1177/27539687221145698.˄

  46. Rainey, Paul B. “Autogenic Transitions in Individuality.” Comptes Rendus. Biologies 349 (2026): 121–29. https://doi.org/10.5802/crbiol.198.˄

  47. Bostrom, Nick. Superintelligence: Paths, Dangers, Strategies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.˄

  48. Cole, Alexandra K., and Sean W. Brillant. “Quantifying Entanglement Risk Reduction to North Atlantic Right Whales from Time-Area Closures in the Southern Gulf of St. Lawrence Snow Crab Fisheries.” Endangered Species Research 57 (2025): 143–59. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr01412.˄

  49. Siders, Zachary A., Robert N. M. Ahrens, Summer Martin, Edward V. Camp, Alexander R. Gaos, John H. Wang, Jamie Marchetti, and T. Todd Jones. “Evaluation of a Long-Term Information Tool Reveals Continued Suitability for Identifying Bycatch Hotspots but Little Effect on Fisher Location Choice.” Biological Conservation 279 (2023): 109912. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2023.109912.˄

  50. Blattner, Charlotte E., Sue Donaldson, and Ryan Wilcox. “Animal Agency in Community: A Political Multispecies Ethnography of VINE Sanctuary.” Politics and Animals 6, no. 1 (2020): 1–22.˄

  51. Hwang, Hochul, Hee-Tae Jung, Nicholas A. Giudice, Joydeep Biswas, Sunghoon Ivan Lee, and Donghyun Kim. “Towards Robotic Companions: Understanding Handler-Guide Dog Interactions for Informed Guide Dog Robot Design.” Proceedings of the 2024 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, 2024, 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1145/3613904.3642181.˄

  52. Bonta, Mark, Robert Gosford, Dick Eussen, Nathan Ferguson, Erana Loveless, and Maxwell Witwer. “Intentional Fire-Spreading by ‘Firehawk’ Raptors in Northern Australia.” Journal of Ethnobiology 37, no. 4 (2017): 700–718. https://doi.org/10.2993/0278-0771-37.4.700.˄


Backlinks