Styles Settled Among Parties

In the styles of this group, several parties settle the choice between them. They pool their contributions, follow a leader or a delegate, adjust to each other, or refuse. The parties can belong to one species, to several species or to different kinds of agent, such as animals and robots or people and programs. Decision Styles defines the terms, the three evidence labels ("proposed", "contested", "model") and the range of agents from nonliving matter to proposed superintelligence. The other groups are Styles Settled by Assessment and Styles Settled by Variation. Hybrid Collectives traces the styles of this group through cases. Each family below has a table of styles with tests and cases, followed by its composition (identity, functions, interactions and possibilities), its overlaps and its disputes.

Pooling Among Many

Many agents contribute, and no member decides alone. Terms in use: collective decision-making, consensus decision, quorum sensing, self-organisation, swarm intelligence, collective intelligence, stigmergy, biological market, voting, deliberation.

StyleHow one option prevailsTestShown in
QuorumMembers commit once enough of them signal or gatherVary the number of signallers; does commitment appear at a threshold?Bacteria;1 viruses that infect Bacillus bacteria and use a peptide signal to choose dormancy;2 rock ants;3 honeybee swarms (Apis mellifera);4 African wild dogs (Lycaon pictus) in Botswana, which depart after enough sneezes, and after fewer sneezes when a dominant dog starts the rally;5 computers in a distributed system, which record a decision once a majority has voted for it;6 robot swarms, whose designers use quorums, majority rules and the copying of a random neighbour as strategies for agreement7
Recruitment and cross-inhibitionSupporters of each option recruit others and inhibit rivals until one option prevailsBlock the inhibiting signal; do deadlocks become more frequent?Honeybee swarms, in which scouts deliver stop signals to dancers for rival sites;8 ants that follow pheromone trails laid by other ants9
Alignment with neighboursEach member adjusts to those nearby, and a few informed members can steer the whole groupAdd a few informed individuals; does the group's direction follow?Fish schools and bird flocks (model and observations);10, 11 olive baboons (Papio anubis) in Kenya, which followed the majority of initiators whatever their rank;12 robots placed among honeybees and zebrafish (Danio rerio), which linked the collective choices of the two species;13 robots that cockroaches treated as group members, which changed the group's choice of shelter even when the robots were in the minority14
Voting and averagingThe group counts signals or averages estimatesVary group size; does accuracy change as aggregation predicts?Departures and changes of activity in many vertebrate groups;15 human juries and electorates, compared with animal groups;16 three people linked by a brain-to-brain interface, in which a receiver combined the signals of two senders and learned to trust the more reliable one;17 four rats with linked brains, which performed several tasks as well as single rats or better18
DeliberationParticipants exchange reasons before the collective choiceCompare choices before and after discussion; did the stated reasons shift them?Human assemblies and deliberative polls,19 whose authority to decide for a wider public is disputed;20 politics with other animals (proposed)21, 22
StigmergyTraces left in the surroundings direct later action by the same agents or by othersErase the trace; does coordination fail?Termites, for whose nest building a zoologist introduced the term in 1959, and ants;23 plants (proposed);24 comparable cases include slime moulds that avoid their own trails25 and burrowing owls (Athene cunicularia) in Idaho, which reused artificial burrows more often when the old nest material remained26
Exchange and pricesEach party adjusts what it gives to what it receives, and rates of exchange transmit the informationChange supply on one side; do rates of exchange shift?Plants and mycorrhizal fungi that give more to the better partner;27 biological markets, in which supply and demand set the terms of exchange between partners;28 price systems in human economies, which, according to a classic argument in economics, pass on knowledge that no single person possesses and so coordinate people's separate actions29
Synchronised timingMembers respond to a shared cue at the same timeShift the cue for part of the population; does synchrony break?Mast seeding in trees and other perennial plants30
  • Composition.
    • Identity: A collective at which the decision closes. Observers can describe one event as many members that signal or as one colony that switches, and Agency asks whether regulation closes at the level of the collective or an analyst has summed the members.
    • Functions: communication; coordination and alignment; collective decision; memory kept in the surroundings; and membership tests.
    • Interactions: Signals and traces pass among many members, and thresholds or weights combine them.
    • Possibilities: A pool registers more options than any member does, because the ranges of the members differ. No member owns the decision, so these styles depend on numbers and on signal channels. Human action that thins a group or masks its signals can stop the decision without harm to any individual. Ozone, for example, degrades the volatile compounds through which plants and insects communicate.31 Traces can direct choices after the event that left them: old nest material influenced the owls' choices in later years.26
  • Complications and overlaps. A pool at one level acts as one assessor at the next: a colony's quorum is the colony's threshold switch. Leadership arises inside pools. A few informed members can steer a school,10 and African wild dogs depart after fewer sneezes when a dominant dog starts the rally.5 Aggregation can also occur in one member. The receiver in the brain-to-brain experiment weighed two senders,17 and reviewers of human groups distinguish aggregation within one mind or by an arbiter from aggregation through interaction.32 Exchange overlaps with partner choice, and stigmergy overlaps with memory kept outside the body. Robotics separates two problems that this family keeps together: agreement on one option, and the division of members among tasks.7 Pools can cross kinds of agent, as the robots among cockroaches, bees and fish show.14, 13 One comparison places nonliving and living collectives on a continuum and proposes that living collectives differ because they control their own state (proposed).33 One proposal groups immune systems with ant colonies, slime moulds and some microbiomes as liquid brains, whose agents move and keep no persistent connections (proposed).34
  • Controversies and incompatibilities. Researchers dispute when a pool outperforms its best member. Reviewers of human and animal groups argue that collective intelligence beyond simple aggregation depends on rules that use the differences among members: weighting inputs by accuracy or expertise, and dividing labour.32 In a model, a randomly selected team outperformed a team of the best performers.35 How honeybee scouts sense a quorum remains unknown.4 The authority of a deliberating sample to decide for a wider public is disputed,20 and politics with other animals is a proposal.21, 22 One forecast describes a collective superintelligence, a system of many smaller intellects whose joint performance would vastly exceed that of any present system (proposed).36 Shared decisions are incompatible with dominance: in a model, they usually cost members less than the decisions of a despot.37 A pool also fails when a written rule replaces its signals, or when it becomes too small.

Leading and Delegating

One agent or a few agents decide for many. Terms in use: leadership, despotic decision, dominance, expertise, representation, guardianship, stewardship, levels of automation, rewilding.

StyleHow one option prevailsTestShown in
DominanceOne member's choice binds the othersDoes the group follow one individual whatever the others need?Chacma baboons (Papio ursinus) in Namibia, which followed the dominant male to a feeding site that favoured him;38 models in which democratic decisions usually cost the group less than despotic ones (model);37 command-and-control management of natural resources39
Leadership granted by followersOthers follow those who have knowledge, need or initiative, also across speciesRemove or replace the leader; does the group's performance change?African elephant families (Loxodonta africana), in which older matriarchs assessed danger from lions more accurately;40 day octopuses (Octopus cyanea) and fish that hunt together in the Red Sea;41 mammal societies compared;42 trees and birds that guide design decisions;43, 44 powerful owls (Ninox strenua) that assess a new design of nest, where a pair moves in or moves on45
Representation and guardianshipAn appointed party decides for another party that cannot take part directlyDoes the outcome follow the observed preferences of the represented party?Rivers with legal personhood and guardians;46, 47 political representation of animals (proposed);48, 49 organisations that give nonhuman life a representative in governance50
Expert judgementTrained specialists decide under professional standardsDo experts outperform simple rules on recorded cases?Structured elicitation from experts;51 conservation practice, in which most decisions rested on experience and anecdote when researchers surveyed it;52 professional design53
Delegation to automated systemsA set of rules or a learned model decides, with more or less human oversightRemove the human check; do outcomes change?Levels of automation;54 algorithmic decisions in organisations;55 farm technologies, some of which let animals adjust their own conditions, for example through voluntary milking;56 three forms of a superintelligent system (proposed): an oracle that answers questions; a genie that executes one command and then awaits the next; a sovereign that pursues broad aims under an open mandate36
Ceding to other species and processesHumans withdraw and other agents decideAfter withdrawal, do outcomes follow the activity of the other agents?Rewilding;57 dam building by beavers (Castor fiber and Castor canadensis) in river restoration58, 59
  • Composition.
    • Identity: A leader or a delegate, and those who follow or are represented. Others often declare the identity of a represented party, as when a statute makes a river a legal person, and the represented party may not share that description.
    • Functions: influence over shared decisions; communication; coordination and alignment; and memory.
    • Interactions: Directed and unequal: A decides for B. Agentic Stair asks whether B can refuse with effect and which third party mediates or profits.
    • Possibilities: The power to steer concentrates in a few agents, which is fast and limited to what those agents register. These styles raise the question of accountability. A represented party often cannot correct its representative, and representation alone does not show that the represented party takes part. Plants, for example, cannot give consent to those who seek to represent them.44
  • Complications and overlaps. Leadership depends on followers, so it overlaps with pooling and with refusal: followers who stay away end it. People who had seen a forecasting algorithm err chose a human forecaster over it, although such algorithms predict more accurately than human forecasters do.60 Guardianship uses written rules, and expert judgement uses stored professional standards. When humans cede, the withdrawal is their decision, and what follows belongs to the styles of the agents that then act. One scheme of participation orders such arrangements: under paternalism, humans keep deciding what is best for other beings, and under autonomy, those beings have the power to pursue their own interests.61
  • Controversies and incompatibilities. Researchers dispute whether leaders serve those whom they lead. Chacma baboons followed a dominant male to a site that favoured him,38 while older elephant matriarchs assessed danger from lions more accurately than younger ones.40 Makers of milking robots say that decisions pass from the farmer to the cow, and a study of farms found that farmers nudge, coerce and train cows and gain new means of control from the robots' data.62 Analysts of participation warn that authority over decisions often concentrates in those who control technical systems.63 For superintelligent systems, the forecast states that the three forms differ less in what they could do than in the precautions that each allows. It adds that the power to stop a genie is a weaker safeguard than it appears (proposed).36 Delegation is incompatible with refusal by the represented party when nobody can correct the delegate, as the cases of river guardians in Hybrid Collectives show.

Adjusting Between Parties

Parties with different interests respond to each other until an arrangement stands. Terms in use: partner choice, sanction, reciprocity, negotiation, contest, signalling, manipulation, ecological trap, co-adaptation, coexistence.

StyleHow one option prevailsTestShown in
Partner choice and sanctionsEach party gives more to partners that give more and less to partners that give lessMake one partner less cooperative; does the other reduce its supply to that partner?Soybean plants (Glycine max) that penalise root nodules whose bacteria are kept from fixing nitrogen, possibly through a reduced oxygen supply;64 plants and mycorrhizal fungi;27 immune systems of animals, which admit and support the microbes that help the body, exclude or kill others and watch for cells that defect, so that what counts as self changes with context (review);65 general accounts of cooperation66
ReciprocityA party returns help later, directly or through a wider circleDoes help received predict help given?Common vampire bats (Desmodus rotundus) in a captive colony, in which the food that a bat received from a partner predicted the food that it gave to that partner better than kinship did;67 reciprocal contributions between people and other beings in customary practice;68 transfers between trees through fungal networks (contested)69
Mutual adjustmentEach party changes its behaviour in response to the other until a workable pattern standsChange one party's behaviour; does the other adjust?Wild mammals on six continents that became more nocturnal where humans are active;70 co-adaptation of humans and large carnivores71
ContestParties escalate or yield according to the costsChange the cost of escalation; does the outcome change?Models in which limited fighting benefits individual animals (model);72 conflict between groups in many taxa;73 agonistic politics among humans74
Signals across speciesParties exchange signals that align their actionsWithhold or alter the signal; does joint success fall?Greater honeyguides (Indicator indicator) and Yao honey-hunters in Mozambique;75 bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus gephyreus) and net-casting fishers in Laguna, Brazil;76, 77 groupers and moray eels that hunt together78
Steering another's choiceA signal or structure from one party triggers the other party's evolved or learned rule, or acts on its body directlyRemove the cue; does the choice return to its earlier pattern?Rats infected with the parasite Toxoplasma gondii, which lose their avoidance of cat odour;79 ecological traps, in which animals prefer habitat where they fare worse;80, 81 recorded song that attracts birds to suitable sites that stood empty;82 beetles (Mecynorrhina torquata and Cotinis texana) whose flight researchers started, stopped and turned by radio through electrodes in the brain and in flight muscles, while each beetle powered and levelled its own flight83
  • Composition.
    • Identity: Two or more parties whose goals align in part. Each party acts on a model of the other, and that model can be wrong or open to exploitation.
    • Functions: communication; valence; membership tests; influence over shared decisions; and refusal.
    • Interactions: Reciprocal and repeated. The relation runs in both directions, and the standing of each party toward the other can differ.
    • Possibilities: Arrangements accumulate over repeated encounters, and the acts of each party change the options of the other. Design often works through steering, because every structure offers cues. A cue that attracts an animal to a place where it fares worse turns a design into a trap.
  • Complications and overlaps. Each style here has a neighbour in another family. Partner choice becomes exchange and prices when many partners trade. A signal across species becomes leadership when one party follows the other over many decisions, as honey-hunters follow honeyguides. Mutual adjustment becomes tradition when it persists across generations. The border between steering and communication is unclear, because the same signal can inform a receiver or exploit its rule. The steered beetle shows the far end of that range: the operator issued the turns, and the beetle's own control kept it in the air.83 Adjustment also occurs between people and machines. In five studies with 7,917 people, participants treated machines differently from humans in a staged society of helpers, punishers and trustors.84 One book on biological individuality treats the mechanisms that keep the parts of a body or a colony together as answers to the same problem of cooperation, and it pairs them with social devices such as commitment devices, signals of identity and lotteries.85
  • Controversies and incompatibilities. Researchers dispute where communication ends and manipulation begins. Transfers between trees through fungal networks are contested.69 In the vampire bats, the link between food received and food given appeared in totals over two years and was weak from one trial to the next. The authors read the pattern as long-term bonds.67 Adjustment is often unequal: wild mammals on six continents became more nocturnal where humans are active.70 Political theory disputes whether contest or reasoned agreement should settle human conflicts.74, 19 Steering is incompatible with consent when the cue bypasses the other party's evaluation.

Refusing and Leaving

An agent declines, departs or blocks. Terms in use: refusal, avoidance, exit, dispersal, resistance, veto, consent, algorithm aversion.

StyleHow one option prevailsTestShown in
Avoidance and non-useThe agent declines an offered conditionOffer the condition where the agent is present; does the agent use it?Nest boxes near Junee, New South Wales, that superb parrots (Polytelis swainsonii) did not use, although the parrots occur within 1 to 2 km of the sites;86 by contrast, Carnaby's cockatoos (Calyptorhynchus latirostris) at Coomallo Creek, Western Australia, used artificial hollows more often than natural ones;87 people who had seen a forecasting algorithm err and then chose a human forecaster over it60
Exit and dispersalThe agent leaves a group or a placeLower local quality; does departure rise?Dispersal decisions in animals, plants and ciliates, tested in the ciliate Tetrahymena;88 species that shift their ranges as the climate changes89
ResistanceThe agent opposes or obstructs an arrangementDoes opposition recur while the arrangement persists?Asian elephants (Elephas maximus) that grew used to sound and light deterrents and returned;90 animals that transgress the places that humans assign to them;91, 92 floodwaters and beavers in the Bow Valley, Alberta, Canada, interpreted as refusals of colonial infrastructure (proposed);93 superintelligent agents that would protect their own survival and their goals from interference, whatever those goals are (proposed)36
Veto and consentOne party's signal stops or permits a joint actDoes the act stop when the party gives the signal?Consent as a principle of research with animals, given through guardians and through the animals' own engagement or withdrawal (proposed);94 choice and control for zoo animals;95 an oracle built to refuse a question when it predicts that an answer would have catastrophic consequences (proposed)36
  • Composition.
    • Identity: The agent that declines. Observers have to show that it was present and able to accept before they read non-use as refusal, and the parties may describe the same act differently.
    • Functions: refusal; valence; and communication.
    • Interactions: A refusal answers a proposal of another party, and it has effect only when that party heeds it.
    • Possibilities: A refusal removes an option from what the parties negotiate, and exit requires another place to go. Refusal is the response that design can observe most easily. An observer has to record presence first, because an unused structure can mean refusal, absence or exclusion by other occupants.
  • Complications and overlaps. Refusal completes other styles. An agent that opts out of a hard choice refuses within valuing. A party that gives less to a poor partner, or leaves it, refuses within partner choice. Followers who do not follow end a leader's influence. A refusal becomes a veto when a rule binds the other party to heed it. Hybrid Collectives gives cases on both sides of that line.
  • Controversies and incompatibilities. Researchers dispute what non-use shows. In one test of prototype hollows in Melbourne, other species used the prototypes and no powerful owl (Ninox strenua) visited the host sites, so the result records absence and leaves refusal open.96 Researchers also dispute whether the word resistance fits animals: a study of cows and milking robots rejects it.62 Readings of floods and beavers as refusals are proposals.93 One design account counts a refusal only when the outcome changes.43 Refusal is incompatible with representation when a guardian can speak and cannot stop. It is incompatible with steering when a cue leaves no option to decline. For superintelligent agents, the forecast predicts that an agent will protect its own survival as a means to almost any goal, and present programs could test that prediction (proposed).36

References


Footnotes

  1. Waters, Christopher M., and Bonnie L. Bassler. “Quorum Sensing: Cell-to-Cell Communication in Bacteria.” Annual Review of Cell and Developmental Biology 21, no. 1 (2005): 319–46. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.cellbio.21.012704.131001.˄

  2. Erez, Zohar, Ida Steinberger-Levy, Maya Shamir, Shany Doron, Avigail Stokar-Avihail, Yoav Peleg, Sarah Melamed, et al. “Communication between Viruses Guides Lysis–Lysogeny Decisions.” Nature 541, no. 7638 (2017): 488–93. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature21049.˄

  3. Pratt, Stephen C., Eamonn B. Mallon, David J. T. Sumpter, and Nigel R. Franks. “Quorum Sensing, Recruitment, and Collective Decision-Making during Colony Emigration by the Ant Leptothorax albipennis.” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 52, no. 2 (2002): 117–27. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-002-0487-x.˄

  4. Seeley, Thomas D. Honeybee Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2010.˄

  5. Walker, Reena H., Andrew J. King, J. Weldon McNutt, and Neil R. Jordan. “Sneeze to Leave: African Wild Dogs (Lycaon pictus) Use Variable Quorum Thresholds Facilitated by Sneezes in Collective Decisions.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 284, no. 1862 (2017): 20170347. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2017.0347.˄

  6. Lamport, Leslie. “The Part-Time Parliament.” ACM Transactions on Computer Systems 16, no. 2 (1998): 133–69. https://doi.org/10.1145/279227.279229.˄

  7. Valentini, Gabriele, Eliseo Ferrante, and Marco Dorigo. “The Best-of-n Problem in Robot Swarms: Formalization, State of the Art, and Novel Perspectives.” Frontiers in Robotics and AI 4 (2017): 9. https://doi.org/10.3389/frobt.2017.00009.˄

  8. Seeley, Thomas D., P. Kirk Visscher, Thomas Schlegel, Patrick M. Hogan, Nigel R. Franks, and James A. R. Marshall. “Stop Signals Provide Cross Inhibition in Collective Decision-Making by Honeybee Swarms.” Science 335, no. 6064 (2012): 108–11. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1210361.˄

  9. Camazine, Scott, Jean-Louis Deneubourg, Nigel R. Franks, James Sneyd, Guy Theraulaz, and Eric Bonabeau. Self-Organization in Biological Systems. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2001.˄

  10. Couzin, Iain D., Jens Krause, Nigel R. Franks, and Simon A. Levin. “Effective Leadership and Decision-Making in Animal Groups on the Move.” Nature 433, no. 7025 (2005): 513–16. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature03236.˄

  11. Couzin, Iain D. “Collective Cognition in Animal Groups.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 13, no. 1 (2009): 36–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2008.10.002.˄

  12. Strandburg-Peshkin, Ariana, Damien R. Farine, Iain D. Couzin, and Margaret C. Crofoot. “Shared Decision-Making Drives Collective Movement in Wild Baboons.” Science 348, no. 6241 (2015): 1358–61. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aaa5099.˄

  13. Bonnet, Frank, Rob Mills, Martina Szopek, Sarah Schönwetter-Fuchs, José Halloy, Stjepan Bogdan, Luís Correia, Francesco Mondada, and Thomas Schmickl. “Robots Mediating Interactions between Animals for Interspecies Collective Behaviors.” Science Robotics 4, no. 28 (2019): eaau7897. https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.aau7897.˄

  14. Halloy, José, Grégory Sempo, Gilles Caprari, Colette Rivault, Masoud Asadpour, Fabien Tâche, Imen Saïd, et al. “Social Integration of Robots into Groups of Cockroaches to Control Self-Organized Choices.” Science 318, no. 5853 (2007): 1155–58. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1144259.˄

  15. Conradt, Larissa, and Timothy J. Roper. “Consensus Decision Making in Animals.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 20, no. 8 (2005): 449–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2005.05.008.˄

  16. Conradt, Larissa, and Christian List. “Group Decisions in Humans and Animals: A Survey.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 364, no. 1518 (2009): 719–42. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2008.0276.˄

  17. Jiang, Linxing, Andrea Stocco, Darby M. Losey, Justin A. Abernethy, Chantel S. Prat, and Rajesh P. N. Rao. “BrainNet: A Multi-Person Brain-to-Brain Interface for Direct Collaboration between Brains.” Scientific Reports 9, no. 1 (2019): 6115. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-41895-7.˄

  18. Pais-Vieira, Miguel, Gabriela Chiuffa, Mikhail Lebedev, Amol Yadav, and Miguel A. L. Nicolelis. “Building an Organic Computing Device with Multiple Interconnected Brains.” Scientific Reports 5, no. 1 (2015): 11869. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep11869.˄

  19. Fishkin, James S. When the People Speak: Deliberative Democracy and Public Consultation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009.˄

  20. Lafont, Cristina. “Deliberation, Participation, and Democratic Legitimacy: Should Deliberative Mini-Publics Shape Public Policy?” Journal of Political Philosophy 23, no. 1 (2015): 40–63. https://doi.org/10.1111/jopp.12031.˄

  21. Meijer, Eva. When Animals Speak: Toward an Interspecies Democracy. New York: New York University Press, 2019.˄

  22. Donaldson, Sue. “Animal Agora: Animal Citizens and the Democratic Challenge.” Social Theory and Practice 46, no. 4 (2020): 709–35. https://doi.org/10.5840/soctheorpract202061296.˄

  23. Theraulaz, Guy, and Eric Bonabeau. “A Brief History of Stigmergy.” Artificial Life 5, no. 2 (1999): 97–116. https://doi.org/10.1162/106454699568700.˄

  24. Sims, Ric, and Özlem Yilmaz. “Stigmergic Coordination and Minimal Cognition in Plants.” Adaptive Behavior 31, no. 3 (2023): 265–80. https://doi.org/10.1177/10597123221150817.˄

  25. Reid, Chris R., Tanya Latty, Audrey Dussutour, and Madeleine Beekman. “Slime Mold Uses an Externalized Spatial ‘Memory’ to Navigate in Complex Environments.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109, no. 43 (2012): 17490–94. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1215037109.˄

  26. Riding, Corey S., and James R. Belthoff. “Removal of Old Nest Material Decreases Reuse of Artificial Burrows by Burrowing Owls.” Wildlife Society Bulletin 39, no. 3 (2015): 521–28. https://doi.org/10.1002/wsb.552.˄

  27. Kiers, E. Toby, Marie Duhamel, Yugandhar Beesetty, Jerry A. Mensah, Oscar Franken, Erik Verbruggen, Carl R. Fellbaum, et al. “Reciprocal Rewards Stabilize Cooperation in the Mycorrhizal Symbiosis.” Science 333, no. 6044 (2011): 880–82. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1208473.˄

  28. Noë, Ronald, and Peter Hammerstein. “Biological Markets: Supply and Demand Determine the Effect of Partner Choice in Cooperation, Mutualism and Mating.” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 35, no. 1 (1994): 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00167053.˄

  29. Hayek, Friedrich A. “The Use of Knowledge in Society.” American Economic Review 35, no. 4 (1945): 519–30.˄

  30. Kelly, Dave, and Victoria L. Sork. “Mast Seeding in Perennial Plants: Why, How, Where?” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 33, no. 1 (2002): 427–47. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.33.020602.095433.˄

  31. Masui, Noboru, Evgenios Agathokleous, Tomoki Mochizuki, Akira Tani, Hideyuki Matsuura, and Takayoshi Koike. “Ozone Disrupts the Communication between Plants and Insects in Urban and Suburban Areas: An Updated Insight on Plant Volatiles.” Journal of Forestry Research 32, no. 4 (2021): 1337–49. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11676-020-01287-4.˄

  32. Kameda, Tatsuya, Wataru Toyokawa, and R. Scott Tindale. “Information Aggregation and Collective Intelligence beyond the Wisdom of Crowds.” Nature Reviews Psychology 1, no. 6 (2022): 345–57. https://doi.org/10.1038/s44159-022-00054-y.˄

  33. Kim, Hyunju, Gabriele Valentini, Jake Hanson, and Sara Imari Walker. “Informational Architecture across Non-Living and Living Collectives.” Theory in Biosciences 140, no. 4 (2021): 325–41. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12064-020-00331-5.˄

  34. Solé, Ricard, Melanie Moses, and Stephanie Forrest. “Liquid Brains, Solid Brains.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 374, no. 1774 (2019): 20190040. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2019.0040.˄

  35. Hong, Lu, and Scott E. Page. “Groups of Diverse Problem Solvers Can Outperform Groups of High-Ability Problem Solvers.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 101, no. 46 (2004): 16385–89. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0403723101.˄

  36. Bostrom, Nick. Superintelligence: Paths, Dangers, Strategies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.˄

  37. Conradt, Larissa, and Timothy J. Roper. “Group Decision-Making in Animals.” Nature 421, no. 6919 (2003): 155–58. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature01294.˄

  38. King, Andrew J., Caitlin M. S. Douglas, Elise Huchard, Nick J. B. Isaac, and Guy Cowlishaw. “Dominance and Affiliation Mediate Despotism in a Social Primate.” Current Biology 18, no. 23 (2008): 1833–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2008.10.048.˄

  39. Holling, Crawford S., and Gary K. Meffe. “Command and Control and the Pathology of Natural Resource Management.” Conservation Biology 10, no. 2 (1996): 328–37. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1523-1739.1996.10020328.x.˄

  40. McComb, Karen, Graeme Shannon, Sarah M. Durant, Katito Sayialel, Rob Slotow, Joyce Poole, and Cynthia Moss. “Leadership in Elephants: The Adaptive Value of Age.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 278, no. 1722 (2011): 3270–76. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2011.0168.˄

  41. Sampaio, Eduardo, Vivek H. Sridhar, Fritz A. Francisco, Máté Nagy, Ada Sacchi, Ariana Strandburg-Peshkin, Paul Nührenberg, Rui Rosa, Iain D. Couzin, and Simon Gingins. “Multidimensional Social Influence Drives Leadership and Composition-Dependent Success in Octopus–Fish Hunting Groups.” Nature Ecology & Evolution 8, no. 11 (2024): 2072–84. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-024-02525-2.˄

  42. Smith, Jennifer E., Sergey Gavrilets, Monique Borgerhoff Mulder, Paul L. Hooper, Claire El Mouden, Daniel Nettle, Christoph Hauert, et al. “Leadership in Mammalian Societies: Emergence, Distribution, Power, and Payoff.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 31, no. 1 (2016): 54–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2015.09.013.˄

  43. Roudavski, Stanislav, and Alexander Holland. “Are You Blocking Nonhuman Leadership? Five Questions to Find Out.” In PDC ’26: Proceedings of the 19th Participatory Design Conference, vol. 2, edited by Laura Galluzzo, Anna Meroni, Daniela Selloni, Davide Fassi, Daniela de Sainz, Andrea Botero, Stefana Broadbent, et al., 372–81. New York: Association for Computing Machinery, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1145/3789492.3796416.˄

  44. Rutten, Julian, Alexander Holland, and Stanislav Roudavski. “Plants as Designers of Better Futures: Can Humans Let Them Lead?” Plant Perspectives 2, no. 1 (2024): 92–139. https://doi.org/10.3197/whppp.63845494909729.˄

  45. Roudavski, Stanislav. “The Case for Nonhuman Leadership.” Interactions 33, no. 6 (2026): 64–67. https://doi.org/10.1145/3849465.˄

  46. O’Donnell, Erin, and Julia Talbot-Jones. “Creating Legal Rights for Rivers: Lessons from Australia, New Zealand, and India.” Ecology and Society 23, no. 1 (2018): 7. https://doi.org/10.5751/es-09854-230107.˄

  47. Stone, Christopher D. “Should Trees Have Standing? Toward Legal Rights for Natural Objects.” Southern California Law Review 45 (1972): 450–501.˄

  48. Donaldson, Sue, and Will Kymlicka. Zoopolis: A Political Theory of Animal Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.˄

  49. Magaña, Pablo. “The Political Representation of Nonhuman Animals.” Social Theory and Practice 48, no. 4 (2022): 665–90. https://doi.org/10.5840/soctheorpract2022811171.˄

  50. Pedroso-Roussado, Cristiano, Klaas Kuitenbrouwer, Vera Fearns, Mariana Pestana, Valentina Nisi, Ann Light, and Nuno Jardim Nunes. “Zoöp Futures: Towards an Organisational Framework for Ecological Cooperation between Humans and More-than-Humans.” Futures 169 (2025): 103584. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2025.103584.˄

  51. Mukherjee, Nibedita, Jean Hugé, William J. Sutherland, Jeffrey McNeill, Maarten Van Opstal, Farid Dahdouh-Guebas, and Nico Koedam. “The Delphi Technique in Ecology and Biological Conservation: Applications and Guidelines.” Methods in Ecology and Evolution 6, no. 9 (2015): 1097–109. https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210x.12387.˄

  52. Sutherland, William J., Andrew S. Pullin, Paul M. Dolman, and Teri M. Knight. “The Need for Evidence-Based Conservation.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 19, no. 6 (2004): 305–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2004.03.018.˄

  53. Cross, Nigel. “Designerly Ways of Knowing.” Design Studies 3, no. 4 (1982): 221–27. https://doi.org/10.1016/0142-694x(82)90040-0.˄

  54. Parasuraman, Raja, Thomas B. Sheridan, and Christopher D. Wickens. “A Model for Types and Levels of Human Interaction with Automation.” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics - Part A: Systems and Humans 30, no. 3 (2000): 286–97. https://doi.org/10.1109/3468.844354.˄

  55. Mahmud, Hasan, A. K. M. Najmul Islam, Syed Ishtiaque Ahmed, and Kari Smolander. “What Influences Algorithmic Decision-Making? A Systematic Literature Review on Algorithm Aversion.” Technological Forecasting and Social Change 175 (2022): 121390. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2021.121390.˄

  56. Dawkins, Marian Stamp. “Does Smart Farming Improve or Damage Animal Welfare? Technology and What Animals Want.” Frontiers in Animal Science 2 (2021): 736536. https://doi.org/10.3389/fanim.2021.736536.˄

  57. Perino, Andrea, Henrique M. Pereira, Laetitia M. Navarro, Néstor Fernández, James M. Bullock, Silvia Ceaușu, Ainara Cortés-Avizanda, et al. “Rewilding Complex Ecosystems.” Science 364, no. 6438 (2019): eaav5570. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aav5570.˄

  58. Brazier, Richard E., Alan Puttock, Hugh A. Graham, Roger Edward Auster, Kye H. Davies, and Chryssa M. L. Brown. “Beaver: Nature’s Ecosystem Engineers.” WIREs Water 8, no. 1 (2021): e1494. https://doi.org/10.1002/wat2.1494.˄

  59. Lorimer, Jamie. “Worlding and Weirding with Beaver: A More-than-Human Political Ecology of Ecosystem Engineering.” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 50, no. 2 (2025): e12698. https://doi.org/10.1111/tran.12698.˄

  60. Dietvorst, Berkeley J., Joseph P. Simmons, and Cade Massey. “Algorithm Aversion: People Erroneously Avoid Algorithms after Seeing Them Err.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 144, no. 1 (2015): 114–26. https://doi.org/10.1037/xge0000033.˄

  61. Roudavski, Stanislav. “The Ladder of More-than-Human Participation: A Framework for Inclusive Design.” Cultural Science 14, no. 1 (2024): 110–19. https://doi.org/10.2478/csj-2024-0015.˄

  62. Bear, Christopher, and Lewis Holloway. “Beyond Resistance: Geographies of Divergent More-than-Human Conduct in Robotic Milking.” Geoforum 104 (2019): 212–21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2019.04.030.˄

  63. Giaccardi, Elisa, Stanislav Roudavski, and Martín Tironi. “Participation and the Troubles with Intelligence.” In PDC ’26: Proceedings of the 19th Participatory Design Conference 2026, vol. 1, edited by Daniela Selloni, Anna Meroni, Laura Galluzzo, Davide Fassi, Daniela de Sainz, Stefana Broadbent, Angus Campbell, et al., 385–90. New York: Association for Computing Machinery, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1145/3796624.3796632.˄

  64. Kiers, E. Toby, Robert A. Rousseau, Stuart A. West, and R. Ford Denison. “Host Sanctions and the Legume–Rhizobium Mutualism.” Nature 425, no. 6953 (2003): 78–81. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature01931.˄

  65. Gilbert, Scott F., Jan Sapp, and Alfred I. Tauber. “A Symbiotic View of Life: We Have Never Been Individuals.” The Quarterly Review of Biology 87, no. 4 (2012): 325–41. https://doi.org/10.1086/668166.˄

  66. Sachs, Joel L., Ulrich G. Mueller, Thomas P. Wilcox, and James J. Bull. “The Evolution of Cooperation.” The Quarterly Review of Biology 79, no. 2 (2004): 135–60. https://doi.org/10.1086/383541.˄

  67. Carter, Gerald G., and Gerald S. Wilkinson. “Food Sharing in Vampire Bats: Reciprocal Help Predicts Donations More than Relatedness or Harassment.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 280, no. 1753 (2013): 20122573. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2012.2573.˄

  68. Ojeda, Jaime, Anne K. Salomon, James K. Rowe, and Natalie C. Ban. “Reciprocal Contributions between People and Nature: A Conceptual Intervention.” BioScience 72, no. 10 (2022): 952–62. https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biac053.˄

  69. Karst, Justine, Melanie D. Jones, and Jason D. Hoeksema. “Positive Citation Bias and Overinterpreted Results Lead to Misinformation on Common Mycorrhizal Networks in Forests.” Nature Ecology & Evolution 7, no. 4 (2023): 501–11. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-023-01986-1.˄

  70. Gaynor, Kaitlyn M., Cheryl E. Hojnowski, Neil H. Carter, and Justin S. Brashares. “The Influence of Human Disturbance on Wildlife Nocturnality.” Science 360, no. 6394 (2018): 1232–35. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aar7121.˄

  71. Carter, Neil H., and John D. C. Linnell. “Co-Adaptation Is Key to Coexisting with Large Carnivores.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 31, no. 8 (2016): 575–78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2016.05.006.˄

  72. Maynard Smith, John, and George R. Price. “The Logic of Animal Conflict.” Nature 246, no. 5427 (1973): 15–18. https://doi.org/10.1038/246015a0.˄

  73. De Dreu, Carsten K. W., and Zegni Triki. “Intergroup Conflict: Origins, Dynamics and Consequences across Taxa.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 377, no. 1851 (2022): 20210134. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2021.0134.˄

  74. Mouffe, Chantal. “Deliberative Democracy or Agonistic Pluralism?” Social Research 66, no. 3 (1999): 745–58.˄

  75. Spottiswoode, Claire N., Keith S. Begg, and Colleen M. Begg. “Reciprocal Signaling in Honeyguide-Human Mutualism.” Science 353, no. 6297 (2016): 387–89. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aaf4885.˄

  76. Cantor, Maurício, Damien R. Farine, and Fábio G. Daura-Jorge. “Foraging Synchrony Drives Resilience in Human–Dolphin Mutualism.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120, no. 6 (2023): e2207739120. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2207739120.˄

  77. Daura-Jorge, Fábio G., Maurício Cantor, Simon N. Ingram, David Lusseau, and Paulo C. Simões-Lopes. “The Structure of a Bottlenose Dolphin Society Is Coupled to a Unique Foraging Cooperation with Artisanal Fishermen.” Biology Letters 8, no. 5 (2012): 702–5. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2012.0174.˄

  78. Vail, Alexander L., Andrea Manica, and Redouan Bshary. “Referential Gestures in Fish Collaborative Hunting.” Nature Communications 4, no. 1 (2013): 1765. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms2781.˄

  79. Berdoy, Manuel, Joanne P. Webster, and David W. Macdonald. “Fatal Attraction in Rats Infected with Toxoplasma gondii.” Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences 267, no. 1452 (2000): 1591–94. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2000.1182.˄

  80. Schlaepfer, Martin A., Michael C. Runge, and Paul W. Sherman. “Ecological and Evolutionary Traps.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 17, no. 10 (2002): 474–80. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0169-5347(02)02580-6.˄

  81. Demeyrier, Virginie, Marcel M. Lambrechts, Philippe Perret, and Arnaud Grégoire. “Experimental Demonstration of an Ecological Trap for a Wild Bird in a Human-Transformed Environment.” Animal Behaviour 118 (2016): 181–90. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2016.06.007.˄

  82. Ahlering, Marissa A., and John Faaborg. “Avian Habitat Management Meets Conspecific Attraction: If You Build It, Will They Come?” The Auk 123, no. 2 (2006): 301–12. https://doi.org/10.1093/auk/123.2.301.˄

  83. Sato, Hirotaka, Christopher W. Berry, Yoav Peeri, Emen Baghoomian, Brendan E. Casey, Gabriel Lavella, John M. VandenBrooks, Jon F. Harrison, and Michel M. Maharbiz. “Remote Radio Control of Insect Flight.” Frontiers in Integrative Neuroscience 3 (2009): 24. https://doi.org/10.3389/neuro.07.024.2009.˄

  84. Makovi, Kinga, Anahit Sargsyan, Wendi Li, Jean-François Bonnefon, and Talal Rahwan. “Trust within Human-Machine Collectives Depends on the Perceived Consensus about Cooperative Norms.” Nature Communications 14, no. 1 (2023): 3108. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-38592-5.˄

  85. Clarke, Ellen. The Units of Life: Kinds of Individual in Biology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2025.˄

  86. Lindenmayer, David B., Mason Crane, Wade Blanchard, Sachiko Okada, and Rebecca Montague-Drake. “Do Nest Boxes in Restored Woodlands Promote the Conservation of Hollow-Dependent Fauna?” Restoration Ecology 24, no. 2 (2016): 244–51. https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.12306.˄

  87. Saunders, Denis A., Rick Dawson, Peter R. Mawson, and Ross B. Cunningham. “Artificial Hollows Provide an Effective Short-Term Solution to the Loss of Natural Nesting Hollows for Carnaby’s Cockatoo Calyptorhynchus latirostris.” Biological Conservation 245 (2020): 108556. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2020.108556.˄

  88. Thierry, Mélanie, Julien Cote, Elvire Bestion, Delphine Legrand, Jean Clobert, and Staffan Jacob. “The Interplay between Abiotic and Biotic Factors in Dispersal Decisions in Metacommunities.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 379, no. 1907 (2024): 20230137. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2023.0137.˄

  89. Pecl, Gretta T., Miguel B. Araújo, Johann D. Bell, Julia L. Blanchard, Timothy C. Bonebrake, I.-Ching Chen, Timothy D. Clark, et al. “Biodiversity Redistribution under Climate Change: Impacts on Ecosystems and Human Well-Being.” Science 355, no. 6332 (2017): eaai9214. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aai9214.˄

  90. Edelblutte, Émilie, Roopa Krithivasan, and Matthew Nassif Hayek. “Animal Agency in Wildlife Conservation and Management.” Conservation Biology 37, no. 1 (2023): e13853. https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.13853.˄

  91. Philo, Chris, and Chris Wilbert, eds. Animal Spaces, Beastly Places: New Geographies of Human-Animal Relations. London: Routledge, 2000.˄

  92. Hodgetts, Timothy, and Jamie Lorimer. “Animals’ Mobilities.” Progress in Human Geography 44, no. 1 (2020): 4–26. https://doi.org/10.1177/0309132518817829.˄

  93. Dang, Tiffany Kaewen. “The Rite of Water: Other-than-Human Refusals in the Bow Valley.” Antipode 58, no. 1 (2026): e70124. https://doi.org/10.1111/anti.70124.˄

  94. Mancini, Clara, and Eleonora Nannoni. “Relevance, Impartiality, Welfare and Consent: Principles of an Animal-Centered Research Ethics.” Frontiers in Animal Science 3 (2022): 800186. https://doi.org/10.3389/fanim.2022.800186.˄

  95. Brey, Lisa, Megan McNames, Eli McGraw, Lilliana Hassinger, Isabelle Wagoner, and Christena Nippert-Eng. “Providing Choice and Control at the Zoo: A Preliminary Review of Contextual Factors Based on Expert Interviews.” In Proceedings of the ACM 12th International Conference on Animal-Computer Interaction, edited by Ilyena Hirskyj-Douglas, 1–11. New York: Association for Computing Machinery, 2025. https://doi.org/10.1145/3768539.3768556.˄

  96. Parker, Dan, Stanislav Roudavski, Therésa M. Jones, Nick Bradsworth, Bronwyn Isaac, Martin T. Lockett, and Kylie Soanes. “A Framework for Computer-Aided Design and Manufacturing of Habitat Structures for Cavity-Dependent Animals.” Methods in Ecology and Evolution 13, no. 4 (2022): 826–41. https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210x.13806.˄


Backlinks