For full text search please use the '?' prefix. e.g. ? Onboarding

Eel Encounters

This note collects single encounters between people and eels, such as anecdotes, local stories, eyewitness records or press reports. Such accounts rarely count as evidence on their own. They show where eels unsettle human plans, institutions or feelings. That makes them useful for teaching, writing and design briefs. Each entry gives its place and source. It separates what the source reports from this note's reading, then ends with the questions it raises. Most sources come from outside the peer-reviewed literature, so entries link to them directly.

Australia

Hyde Park, Perth (2023)

  • What happened. At 9.52 pm on 22 August 2023, Dominic Williams photographed a short-finned eel in a pond at Hyde Park, Perth, then posted the observation to iNaturalist. He reports at least two eels in the park. iNaturalist classes the species as introduced in Western Australia.
  • The observer's account of their origin. He attributes the eels to a Northbridge seafood market that sells live eels, together with Buddhist life release by people unaware of its ecological impact. He photographed smaller eels at the market before the owner made him leave. He also asks why live eels from other states can be sold as food when trading "any live animal native to another state or territory as a pet" is illegal.
  • Turtles. He reports that a 2015 University of Western Australia survey of the park's turtles caught an eel by accident. By his account, eggs still hatch, yet no turtle recruitment has succeeded at Hyde Park for over 15 years. He has helped hatchlings reach the water since 2018, and he suspects that the eels eat them.
  • Responsibility. By his account, the City of Vincent would spend $5,000 on a further university study in 2022 yet would not address predation by eels. The city called the eels a matter for the state fisheries department, which disowned the task.
  • Other sightings. Commenters on the record report eels in a lake at Hillarys, "rumored to be from the restaurant trade". One calls Hyde Park "a bit of a fish dumping ground", while another recalls seeing an eel there years earlier. The observer adds a short-finned eel in a turtle pond at Landsdale.
  • Readings. The points below are this note's own.
    • Care that harms. A release meant as compassion leaves a migratory fish in an urban pond with no evident route to the sea. Such an eel may live for years, as the eels in Melbourne Museum's Milarri Pond have, but it probably cannot complete its migration to spawn.
    • One species, two statuses. The short-finned eel is Near Threatened at species level, and Victoria manages it under a fishery plan. In Perth the same species appears as a suspected predator of turtle hatchlings. See Status in Victoria.
    • A gap in responsibility. Trade brought live eels to Perth. Once released, they fell between a city that manages parks and an agency that manages fisheries.
    • A lone witness. The observer spent more than five months gathering evidence of the eels. A comment on his record, "I knew I wasn't crazy", shows how a shared record can turn private sightings into corroboration.
  • Questions.
    • Do the eels eat turtle hatchlings, and could diet studies or cameras show it?
    • What do Western Australian rules say about selling live eels or releasing them?
    • How do Buddhist communities in Perth understand life release, and what alternatives would they welcome?
    • Who should decide what happens to the released eels, and how could the eels' own needs count in that decision?

Encounters in Other Notes

The accounts below appear in other notes, with their sources. Each line links to the full entry.

  • Eels on the tennis courts (Parkville, Melbourne). Anecdotes describe eels crossing the tennis courts of the old Vice-Chancellor's residence at the University of Melbourne after heavy rain. A Wurundjeri Elder calls eels in Melbourne's drains an urban legend but will not rule them out. Eels of Elizabeth Street in Melbourne
  • A spade in the dam mud (Gippsland, Victoria). In a 1950s childhood, Don Watson killed fat, metre-long eels with a spade when his family cleaned out its dam. His grandmother called eels "the real abomination". Settler Tastes
  • A banquet hall on Muddy Creek (Melbourne). William Barak told of the silver eel run turning Muddy (Koonung) Creek "into a banquet hall". Before and After 1835
  • Eels in a museum pond (Melbourne). About 12 short-finned eels have lived in Milarri Pond at Melbourne Museum for over ten years. Eels in the Present City
  • A friendly eel (Trove, 1928). A 1928 newspaper item titled "A Friendly Eel" appears among the clippings. Indigenous and Local Relations
  • Dead eels in a field (Fens, England). When a storm near Ely ended early, silver eels crossing a field died there. The farmer phoned to ask where they had come from. Climbing and Overland Movement
  • Eels climbing out to die (East Sussex, England). A Guardian piece asks why every fish in an East Sussex fishing lake died overnight, under the headline "The eels were climbing out of the water to die". Die-Offs, Harm and Damage
  • An eel in a well (Brantevik, Sweden). Legend tells of an eel that lived for 155 years in a well. Swedish households reportedly kept eels in wells to clean the water. Longevity
  • Freud's eels (Europe, nineteenth century). As a medical student, Sigmund Freud dissected hundreds of eels in a failed search for male sex organs. Keepers of Uncertainty
  • Pet murenae (Roman Italy). The orator Quintus Hortensius and the triumvir Crassus were said to have wept when their pet eels died. Murenae were adorned with jewellery and trained to come when called by name. Long View

Adding Entries

  • Give each encounter its own ### heading, named by place and year, under a regional ## heading.
  • What happened. Place, date, source and what the source reports.
  • Claims. Causes or judgements that the source asserts, attributed to it. Use separate labelled bullets for distinct claims or actors.
  • Readings. This note's interpretation, marked as such.
  • Questions. What needs checking or could become research.
Backlinks